OMG Internet SIG
Minutes of Meeting #25
November 15, 1999
internet/99-11-01
Attendance
-
Henry Balen - Xenotrope - balen@xenotrope.com
-
Bill Cox - Novell - bill@novell.com
-
Roderick Holland - MITRE/Open Systems Center -
rholland@mitre.org
-
Jeffrey Kurtz - MITRE - jkurtz@mitre.org
-
Kathy Lally - Object Management Group - klally@omg.org
-
Gordon Palumbo - Xenotrope - palumbo@xenotrope.com
-
Henry Rothkopf - MITRE/Open Systems Center - henryr@mitre.org
-
Shel Sutton - MITRE - shel@mitre.org
-
Craig Thompson - Object Services and Consulting -
thompson@objs.com
Minutes
… by Craig Thompson
Presentation: Policies, Procedures, Prototypes, and Pilot Implementations
(P4I) for Coalition Command, Control, Computers and Intelligence (C4I)
and Sustainment, Shel Sutton (MITRE)
DoD need a partnership with industry and activity to solve coalition interoperability
and culture problems. Initial project ideas are Common Information
Assurance tools, CSCW, and visualization tools for common operational picture.
Shel covered the structure of a proposed international coalition (P4I)
for C4I. Global info grid (GIG) is a part of this. See internet-99-11-02
forthcoming.
Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW) Working Group, Henry Rothkopf,
MITRE
Jeff Kurtz and Henry Rothkopf handed out a CSCW
green paper (internet/99-11-03). They described a proposed open
framework architecture for collaboration. The framework was defined
at MITRE and then other groups at Lockeed and elsewhere have been extending
it. This is more than a common session, rather contexts are persistent.
Some things we covered were
-
how the CSCW framework relates to the workflow task and session model and
the notion of roles
-
how security can connect to the CSCW framework
-
how policy might connect to the CSCW framework
-
what other frameworks or services are we involved in
-
whether CSCW framework explains federation of such frameworks
CSCW plan on a Birds of a Feather session later in the week. A potential
RFP might be created. At Mesa several things should happen:
invite more speakers, review revised green paper, review draft RFP, and
plan to meet with other relevant groups in OMG to spread the word.
See Birds of a Feather below for more on CSCW.
Agent Working Group
see separate Minutes
of Agent Work Group
OMG CSCW WG: Birds of a Feather Meeting
November 11, 1999
Attendance
Jeff Kurtz - MITRE - jkurtz@mitre.org
Henry Rothkopf - MITRE - henryr@mitre.org
Ben Steele - Questra - bsteele@questra.com
Brad Bebee - BAH - bebee_bradley@bah.com
Rod Holland - MITRE - rholland@mitre.org
Minutes
Minutes by Jeff Kurtz
Discussion
The group discussed the CSCW object framework presented in the CSCW green
paper (http://www.objs.com/isig/CSCW_WG_Green_Paper-991112.PDF)
and how the concepts relate to OMG facilities and services.
Ben Steele described his participation in an OOPSLA analysis and design
exercise on a related topic: generic tools for CSCW educational
software. He recommends that we contact Michael Whitlaw, the
Australian professor who came up with the design task for the OOPSLA session.
The CSCW framework could align with the E-Commerce framework, workflow,
and the CORBA component model (CCM).
Some recommended additions to the green paper
-
use cases
-
description of the types of collaboration supported
-
assertions about relations with other OMG frameworks